‘Chaos and confusion’: Alberta teachers’ union rebukes education changes

Support LWC on Patreon

Following a flurry of education announcements, the Alberta teachers’ union is calling for more consultation amid changes it said could strain Calgary schools. 

During a news conference hosted by the Alberta Teachers’ Association (ATA) on Nov. 19, president Jason Schilling slammed moves the province made on several pre-weekend dates — acts he called “political distractions.”

“While we welcome the government’s recognition that strong public education is essential to Alberta’s future, we are also calling on them to ensure that any decisions or changes that they make reflect what students need to succeed, both in school and beyond,” Schilling said.

Schilling named a handful of announcements, including October’s Bill 35, which proposed amendments related to reporting student achievement to families, and March’s former Bill 25, which proposed amendments related to political neutrality within school walls. 

Both, along with last week’s updated high school graduation requirements, were allegedly introduced without the ministry consulting parties with industry experience, he argued. While he agreed it was due time to update diploma requirements, he said the others were not a priority.

“These smokescreen decisions affect students’ education without reducing class sizes, improving success or access to supports, or addressing teacher and substitute shortages,” said Schilling.

“These decisions undermine the future of our students, disregard meaningful consultation, and are causing irreparable harm to the morale of teachers who are already fueling the ever-building pressures of this fire hose approach to policy creation in Alberta.”

Minister says students, studies informed the move

The new graduation requirements have been at the top of mind lately, given their recency. When Demetrios Nicolaides, minister of Education and Childcare, spoke to the media on Nov. 13, he said that the decision was partly informed by members of his student advisory council. 

“One of the things that I’ve heard so consistently, repeated consistently, from students, has been the need to make some updates to graduation requirements, and to some of our programming,” he said. 

In the following days, Alberta NDP MLA Janis Irwin, for Edmonton-Highlands-Norwood, asked Minister Nicolaides during question period at the legislative assembly who he consulted before issuing the update. He cited several American research studies.

By 2030, Grade 11 and 12 students will have more room for electives because they will need fewer core credits. Physical education will be mandatory throughout high school, and all students must complete a revised career and life management course to graduate.

NDP leader Naheed Nenshi told reporters Monday that the updated requirements appeared to be the province “dumbing down our standards.” He asked Premier Danielle Smith for clarification during question period, and she defended the changes. 

“We have been hearing from parents that they want financial literacy taught to their children in school, so that when they graduate, they know how to open up a bank account, so that they know how to pay their bills, so that they know how to invest,” said Smith. 

“We have also been told that kids have mental health challenges, and one of the best ways that you can deal with mental health as well as long-term, [is] physical health.

“That’s the reason that we want to make sure that it’s also built into the curriculum.”

Implementation could strain Calgary schools, ATA flags

The ATA initially responded to the updated requirements in an earlier news release, describing concerns about literacy gaps among students who might choose to take the minimum number of core class credits and the post-secondary hurdles that could follow. 

Coupled with this, Schilling said Thursday afternoon that because the government did not consult teachers and leaders, certain implementation challenges went unacknowledged, including whether schools have enough staff to support an influx of students taking electives or adequate gymnasium space to support scheduling more mandatory classes. 

“It’s time for this government to stop making announcements that are intended to misdirect from the real issues and concerns,” he said. 

“Go back to the drawing board and engage education partners before their plans of making announcements that cause chaos and confusion.”

LWC asked both the Calgary Board of Education (CBE) and the Calgary Catholic School District (CCSD) about whether the above are expected to strain school operations over the next four years.

In an email statement, the CBE said that it has not yet received details from the ministry regarding the new graduation requirement and “any impacts on programming, course availability, and resources,” but that it will continue to work with the province.

CCSD said it is aware of the announcement and will “assess the potential impacts of these changes, including course availability, staffing and resources, to determine how best to support students moving forward,” the statement read. 

“Our priority remains ensuring that all students have access to faith-filled learning opportunities that support their interests, while preparing them for success in high school and beyond.”

For future proposals, Schilling asked the government to establish a “clear, transparent process” that involves teachers, parents, school divisions, post-secondary institutions, and professionals before introducing new legislation. 

He concluded by asking the public to contact their MLA to back the union’s request to address grievances that have continued since the strikes, including funding to hire teachers and bolster student success. 

“Meaningful consultation should shape those decisions before, not justify them after the fact,” said Schilling. 

“Albertans have shown time and again, especially during last year’s teachers’ strike, that they support public education. Now we’re asking you, the public, to make your voice heard again.”

“Flood their inboxes, their phone numbers. Contact them daily.”

Liked it? Take a second to support Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Trending articles

Calgary police conduct month-long child safety seat check stops

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

Encampment fire repairs under Calgary bridges cost $2.688 million since 2021

Darren Krause

Calgary’s water utility to send $271M a year to city coffers as rates set to climb

Darren Krause

City finds potential land for Calgary police Belvedere station

Darren Krause

Calgary’s four-year budget breakdown. Where would the money be spent?

Darren Krause

Latest from LiveWire Calgary

Alberta data centre rules are a good start for Calgary, councillors say

Darren Krause

City finds potential land for Calgary police Belvedere station

Darren Krause

Alberta’s new high school graduation requirements raise literacy and university entrance concerns

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

Calgary’s water utility to send $271M a year to city coffers as rates set to climb

Darren Krause

MORE RECENT ARTICLES

Ranchman’s set to move into Schank’s South location

Staff LiveWire Calgary

Calgary forges ahead with research, land-use amendments for large-scale data centres

Darren Krause

Calgary police conduct month-long child safety seat check stops

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

Country Hills widening project opens six paved lanes in the north

Staff LiveWire Calgary