Calgary’s water utility to send $271M a year to city coffers as rates set to climb

Support LWC on Patreon

As Calgarians face a proposed 75 per cent hike in water rates, the city’s water utility is on track to send more than a quarter-billion dollars a year into general city coffers by 2030, a practice Mayor Jeromy Farkas says should be steered back into water infrastructure.

In the proposed 2027-2030 City of Calgary budget documents (p.62), which will be debated starting on Nov. 23, show a steady increase in the water return on equity, based on the planned expansion of the city’s water assets.

That amount is expected to grow from $130 million in 2026 to an estimated $271 million by 2030.

The City of Calgary’s Return on Equity policy, which also governs other self-sustaining public operations like Enmax and Calgary Parking, shows the water utility pays an annual dividend that’s benchmarked at around 8.5 per cent of its equity and asset base.

Before 2021, the water utility paid a flat 10 per cent of revenue back as a dividend to the city, plus a separate franchise fee.  A franchise fee (Local Access Fee), similar to what’s paid by Enmax, is paid in lieu of municipal property taxes on utility infrastructure.

According to the City of Calgary, under a council-directed policy, the payment is directed back into general revenue. It said it reduces the amount the city must collect in municipal property taxes. In 2026, it equated to a reduction of about five per cent in the property tax increase, the city’s response read.

“This funding supports the broader operating budget as The City invests in the services and infrastructure Calgarians rely on every day—including roads, transit, public safety, water and community amenities,” read the City of Calgary’s email response to questions.  

“These budget priorities reflect what Calgarians have told us matters most and support reliable services as our city grows. Redirecting the ROE payment to the water system would leave a gap in the operating budget that would need to be addressed through higher property taxes or reduced municipal services.”

Calgary city council will be asked to approve the proposed increase to water rates during budget deliberations to help pay for the massive water infrastructure investment over the next 10 years.

Cash should be put back into water infrastructure: Mayor Farkas

Mayor Jeromy Farkas said that the water utility’s return-on-equity payment is a standard business practice.

Still, he said that the Bearspaw Independent Review Panel report recommended that the City of Calgary examine how that return on equity should be built and administered.

The panel suggested that the ROE be formalized at 8.5 per cent on 40 per cent of its net undepreciated capital assets. It also said it should transition to standard utility accounting.

“We need to make sure that our return on equity is reasonable, and we need to make sure that we can show Calgarians with a very clear line of sight that every single dollar from their bills are going to capital infrastructure projects,” Mayor Farkas said.

“I think it makes more sense to earmark that return on equity for specific capital improvements that are related to water, say the roads above it, road repair schedules, that sort of thing. But I don’t like the idea of it going into general revenue.”

Ward 10 Coun. Andre Chabot said the City of Calgary has a variety of instruments that generate revenue for the city – including the water utility and Enmax. He said the current return-on-equity rate is lower than that of other utilities.

“For us to continue to maintain that as an internal asset and only collecting eight-and-a-half per cent is actually saving money,” he said.

“If we went to a wholly owned subsidiary, guaranteed that that would get pushed up to at least 10 per cent.”

He said the alternative to not collecting the return on equity payment is raising property taxes.

“This is just one way of collecting taxes from not only Calgary residents but other users outside of the city of Calgary paying into that ROE, so Calgarians are actually getting subsidized a little bit from external customers,” Chabot said.

The City of Calgary said that city council can direct changes to the Return on Equity policy.

“As part of broader changes to the Water Utility, Administration plans to review how the payment is calculated and bring recommendations to Council in 2027,” a response read.

Liked it? Take a second to support Darren Krause on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Trending articles

Encampment fire repairs under Calgary bridges cost $2.688 million since 2021

Darren Krause

Calgary police conduct month-long child safety seat check stops

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

Calgary’s water utility to send $271M a year to city coffers as rates set to climb

Darren Krause

Country Hills widening project opens six paved lanes in the north

Staff LiveWire Calgary

Alberta’s new high school graduation requirements explained

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

Latest from LiveWire Calgary

Alberta’s new high school graduation requirements raise literacy and university entrance concerns

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

Ranchman’s set to move into Schank’s South location

Staff LiveWire Calgary

Calgary forges ahead with research, land-use amendments for large-scale data centres

Darren Krause

Calgary police conduct month-long child safety seat check stops

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

MORE RECENT ARTICLES

Country Hills widening project opens six paved lanes in the north

Staff LiveWire Calgary

Calgary holiday market returns to support young mothers through handcrafted gifts

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

Encampment fire repairs under Calgary bridges cost $2.688 million since 2021

Darren Krause

Police investigate fatal Bowness shooting

Staff LiveWire Calgary