Councillors will debate rollbacks on Calgary’s approved budget

Support LWC on Patreon

The item must first gain 10 city council votes for reconsideration before City of Calgary administration could examine potential cuts.

The biggest debate on an upcoming Notice of Motion to roll back Calgary’s recently approved budget won’t necessarily be whether council should approve it.

It’s likely to be about the political motivation behind the move.

Calgary city councillors unanimously consented to move ahead with debate on a Notice of Motion that would ask city administration to come back with $23 million in cuts to cover the impact of the property tax shift from businesses to homeowners.  It will come to the Jan. 30 regular meeting of council. There it will need at least 10 votes for a reconsideration.

Ward 3 Coun. Jasmine Mian said that while she approved the motion on its technical merits, she doesn’t support the actual plan.

“I think the big issue I have with this is that these councillors are going to harp all day long about efficiency,” she said.

“This is going to create significant inefficiency by telling the organization to do the opposite of what it was told to do three months ago.”

Upon questions from councillors about the technical aspects of the Notice of Motion, City of Calgary Chief Financial Officer Carla Male said that this would be a significant amount of work to tackle for February.

“A program like this, and to deliver that information back by February, effectively puts pencils down on implementation,” she told councillors.

“The reason we have the (budget) deliberations concluding at the end of November, is so that we can have certainty when the year began as to the direction and the services and the capital that we will be spending.”

Political or not?

Ward 7 Coun. Terry Wong, who brought forward the plan, along with five fellow councillors, reiterated Tuesday that this isn’t politically motivated. This is what he’s heard in talks with residents and with community associations across his ward.

“This whole thing is not political. This is not about me against other council members,” he said.  

“This is responding to the public.”

He said he’s not going lobby other councillors to both vote to reconsider the budget and accept a suite of cuts by administration, should it go that far.

“If there’s any lobbying, the lobbying is going to come from their constituents,” Wong said.  

“Their constituents are going to voice just like my constituents, our voice. My constituents said to me, ‘you know, we’ve got challenges, what are you going to do about it?’”

Ward 9 Coun. Gian-Carlo Carra felt it was little more than a political play by a group of councillors bent on making a statement on property taxes.

“I can’t imagine a world where having deliberated the budget the way we deliberated it, and made the tough decisions that we made, that we’re just going to reverse it randomly,” he said.

“But, as I said, politicians have the right to say ‘let’s reverse it randomly.’ So, we’re going to debate that.”

Carra said he’s empathetic to the cost increases that Calgarians are experiencing – but the City of Calgary is experiencing inflationary pressures as well. They’ve just been absorbing those costs over the years to keep property tax pressures at bay.

“We’ve reached the point where we need to backfill if we’re going to achieve the things that Calgarians have asked us to achieve. So, it’s a tough spot to be in,” Carra said.

Coun. Mian also doubled up on the political nature of this Notice of Motion. While it’s important to aim for continuous improvement and thinking projects through, she said political fortunes are to be considered.

“I also think that we’re getting into the silly season a little bit, and some of this is an attempt to tee up mayoral or re-election campaigns,” she said.

“I think if it was about simply listening to Calgarians, they would reconsider things that Calgarians actually find unpopular, like the arena.”

So… motion approved: Where do you want to cut?

Coun. Wong said they’d leave it up to administration to suggest the possible cuts. Then they would vote on whether those cuts were palatable. He said that things like cutting transit hours or peace officers are “no-go territory.”

“We laid out council priorities during our four-year business plan, we laid out what the focus should be for 2024,” he said.  

“If administration wants to violate that, our job as governors, our job as council members, is to push back and say, ‘no, those aren’t the areas we’re looking for. You’re not doing your job if you’re picking those things.’”

Ward 1 Coun. Sonya Sharp rejected the notion from CFO Male that they would likely come back with an across-the-board one per cent cut. She said that’s ‘last resort.’

Sharp said that they could go in surgically to different departments and find the savings. Sharp said she pitched 10 amendments during the last budget deliberations that were “opportunities” to bring this down already. Most, if not all, were voted down 8-7.

“Administration needs to be very mindful in what they bring forward to council, and it is a political decision,” she said.

“But I think they need to leave the politics to us and make sure that they’re the subject matter experts bringing what’s forward, that’s not going to impact Calgarians.”

Ward 13’s Coun. Dan McLean said he thinks programs like the City of Calgary’s secondary suite incentive program could immediately save $30 million.

“That’s $30 million for the lucky three, four thousand people to get $10,000 each to make more money off their homes, that increases the value of their homes,” he said.

(Note: The recently approved Calgary Housing Strategy called for the $10,000 incentive to help create 400 more suites. The City of Calgary did, however, extend the permit fee amnesty through 2026. That’s roughly $679 per application).

He also suggested that the City of Calgary has added more employees to its ranks and questioned if those positions were needed.

Coun. McLean also suggested that he would be in favour of using city reserves to cover a portion – or all – of the proposed tax increases.

Liked it? Take a second to support Darren Krause on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

Trending articles

Encampment fire repairs under Calgary bridges cost $2.688 million since 2021

Darren Krause

Alberta’s new high school graduation requirements explained

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

Police investigate fatal Bowness shooting

Staff LiveWire Calgary

Calgary youth arena ice rental rates proposed to spike in 2027

Darren Krause

Calgary budget nuggets: Here are 15 things you may have missed

Darren Krause

Latest from LiveWire Calgary

Calgary holiday market returns to support young mothers through handcrafted gifts

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

Encampment fire repairs under Calgary bridges cost $2.688 million since 2021

Darren Krause

Police investigate fatal Bowness shooting

Staff LiveWire Calgary

Alberta’s new high school graduation requirements explained

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

MORE RECENT ARTICLES

Calgary youth arena ice rental rates proposed to spike in 2027

Darren Krause

Calgary’s Chapelhow Legion launches fundraising to fix vital roof damage

Sarah Palmer - Local Journalism Initiative

Calgary stays green in week one of Bearspaw feeder main tie-in

Darren Krause

Calgary budget nuggets: Here are 15 things you may have missed

Darren Krause